Tracking Progress Under the Paris Agreement: Transparency and Accountability

Parties to the Paris Agreement agreed to prepare successive Nationally Determined Contributions (NDCs) every five years, including domestic mitigation targets. To track progress on NDC implementation, Parties must submit biennial transparency reports, making transparency vital to building the trust necessary to accelerate ambitious climate action.

Robust voluntary initiatives can demonstrate progress toward ambitious NDCs, and it is important to strengthen their accountability. The High-Level Climate Champions (HLCs) play a fundamental role in activating the ambition loop, the cycle whereby non-Party stakeholders (NPS) and Parties scale-up ambitious climate action. The UNFCCC is upgrading the Global Climate Action Portal (GCAP) for enhanced transparency and accountability of voluntary initiatives.

Assessing the Mandate for Review of the Transparency Modalities, Procedures, and Guidelines

The Paris Agreement’s transparency regime is fully operational. The modalities, procedures, and guidelines—finalized in 2018—underpin the transparency process by providing essential guidance to support standardized reports that feed into the Paris ambition cycle. Its first mandated review will take place “no later than 2028,” and could address substantive areas that have evolved.

To clarify how the mandated review should be carried out, Parties could usefully: (1) signal a clear start date and define predictable review milestones, (2) decide if a clearer end date is needed, (3) center updates on lessons from Party experiences, and (4) focus on targeted clarifications that improve coherence without reopening core political debates.

Read our paper here.

Turning Global Climate Commitments into Implementation: The Critical Role of Transparency

Countries say they want to see climate action—or “implementation.” This requires an answer to a deceptively simple question: what does implementation look like at the multilateral level?

Inside the negotiations, there is an underutilized process that, if better leveraged, could deliver exactly what an implementation COP should do: put a multilateral spotlight on what countries are actually delivering.

Read more analysis here.

A Vision for the 2025-2030 Action Agenda

A 2030 plan for the action agenda should, consistent with the Fourth Letter of the incoming Presidency for the 30th Conference of the Parties (COP30) to the UN Framework Convention on Climate Change (UNFCCC), facilitate follow-up on the outcomes of the first global stocktake (GST) and enhance international cooperation in support of the Paris Agreement five-year ambition cycle. It should also stabilize and streamline a unified approach to better inform the work of Parties and send signals through to 2030. In that context, this discussion paper sets out key recommendations for a Climate High-Level Champions’ (CHLC) five-year plan, including fostering accountability for GST-aligned solutions for the implementation of climate and development priorities, led by international cooperative initiatives.

Read our paper here.

The Paris Agreement’s Enhanced Transparency Framework

Under Enhanced Transparency Framework guidance, Parties must submit biennial reports. These reports disclose country greenhouse gas emissions and removals, adaptation actions and plans, finance and technological support provided and received, and—crucially—progress towards achievement of each Party’s NDC.

Through collaborative review processes, countries are able to share information and best practice while publicly available reports ensure that progress can be monitored, including by civil societies.

Accountability of non-Parties

Businesses, investors, cities, sub-national regions, civil society organizations, NGOs, and other actors play a key role in achieving the long-term goals of the Paris Agreement.

C2ES seeks to support efforts to enhance implementation, tracking, and accountability of voluntary, non-Party stakeholder initiatives.

C2ES’s Role

As climate pledges by countries, non-Party stakeholders, and private sector actors move into implementation and action, C2ES aims to:

• Inform discussions and provide updates on the state of transparency and accountability efforts
• Provide input to Paris Agreement processes and workstreams on reporting and accountability
• Analyze reporting linkages within evolving elements of the climate regime

✕