What are the coal ash disposal (coal combustion residuals disposal) rules?
The residuals of coal combustion in power plants that are captured by pollution control technology, such as scrubbers, are often referred to as coal ash. The waste includes fly ash, bottom ash, boiler slag, flue gas desulfurization gypsum, and other byproducts and contains low concentrations of arsenic, selenium, lead, and mercury. After collection at a power plant, coal ash is often impounded in a surface storage pond or in a landfill.
Like other waste products, coal ash is governed under the Resources Conservation and Recovery Act (RCRA) and is currently considered to be a non-hazardous waste under that law. Through a rulemaking process, EPA is considering whether this designation should be changed.
Who are the covered entities?
Coal-fired power plants in the U.S. produced 136 million tons of coal ash in 2008. Fifty-five percent of that total was disposed of in 584 landfills or surface impoundments nationwide. However, coal ash has some useful purposes; 45 percent of the waste is now recycled into products like concrete and bricks and as filler for abandoned mines and highway berms. New coal ash disposal regulations would affect the 60 million tons of coal ash annual that is disposed of and not recycled, reused, or reclaimed.
What is the status of regulation?
EPA decisions in 1993 and 2000 determined that coal ash should be regulated as a non-hazardous waste under Subtitle D of RCRA, the same classification as household garbage and other nonhazardous industrial wastes. EPA develops guidelines to assist in planning, managing, and implementing disposal of these wastes, although state and local agencies take primary responsibility.
The classification of coal ash as non-hazardous waste has been challenged by recent events. In December 2008, a dam holding a wet storage pond of coal ash from power plants broke in Kingston, Tennessee, spilling about one billion gallons of coal ash-polluted water over 300 acres into the nearby community and waterways. Another spill in October 2011 sent coal ash-polluted water into Lake Michigan. These accidents, along with long held concerns about leaching of pollutants from impoundments to ground water, have led to some advocates to call for a designation as a hazardous waste under RCRA, and EPA proposed rulemaking on the issue in June 2010.
The EPA proposed and sought comment on two options, neither of which would apply to coal ash that is recycled or reused into other products. The first option would classify coal ash as a “special waste” under Subtitle C of RCRA. Ultimately, this designation would require regulations for the generation; transportation; and treatment, storage or disposal of coal ash, along with related compliance and enforcement programs. The second option would be to continue the treatment of coal ash as a non-hazardous waste under Subtitle D of RCRA but also establish minimum requirements for storage. Under both proposals, EPA would establish dam safety requirements to address the structural integrity of surface impoundments to prevent major releases, like those seen recently in Tennessee and Wisconsin.
EPA offered five months of public comment and a year of data collection on these proposals and received over 450,000 comments, and announced that it would delay final decision-making until an unnamed future date. In response, Earthjustice, on behalf of eleven other organizations, announced its intent to sue EPA to conclude its rulemaking. The lawsuit must be filed within 60 days of its January 11, 2012 notice date. EPA has stated that it will finalize revisions to the definition of solid waste by December 2012.
In October 2011, the House of Representatives passed legislation, H.R. 2273, the "Coal Residuals Reuse and Management Act," that would prohibit EPA from regulating coal ash as hazardous waste. While there is companion legislation in the Senate, S. 1751, it is unlikely to advance in the upper chamber.
Read more from EPA on coal ash disposal.